Food Processors, UW Collaborate to Remove Guesswork from Wastewater Disposal
The results of a new research offer some support for the long-held belief that much of the nitrogen in the wastewater leaves the soil and harmlessly enters the atmosphere.
By David Tenenbaum
For more than a century, cheesemakers and vegetable processors have applied water remaining after production to open fields and farmland. The wastewater was used to wash vegetables, or contains whey left over after milk was processed into cheese.
These green beans have passed the first processing at the Del Monte cannery in Cambria. Geoff Siemering (left) and facility manager Al Bodden watch the fast-moving belt coming from semi trucks just outside. PHOTO: DAVID TENENBAUM / UW–MADISON
Over the years, producers have removed most impurities from this wastewater. But there was no definitive answer on whether the remaining nitrogen (in the form of nitrate) was polluting groundwater and residential water wells.
Excess nitrate in drinking water can cause blue baby syndrome, which interferes with the blood’s ability to carry oxygen. Just this month, high levels of nitrate caused by large animal operations have raised concerns in La Crosse County.
The report of a three-year study, jointly funded by industry and the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources, was released today at a meeting in Stevens Point. The results offer some support for the long-held belief that much of the nitrogen in the wastewater leaves the soil and harmlessly enters the atmosphere.
The groundbreaking study also showed that rates of this process, called denitrification, vary depending on season, soil type, crop cover and application rates, says Geoffrey Siemering, a UW–Madison soil contamination specialist.
Because the atmosphere contains about 78 percent nitrogen, measuring transfers from the soil is extremely difficult, says study leader Francisco Arriaga, a professor of soil science. The automated technology developed in his lab captures and measures nitrogen as it escapes to the atmosphere. Efforts by Ph.D. candidate Clay Vanderleest were instrumental in developing this technology for the study.
“We expected to be surprised, as this important measurement has never, to our knowledge, been possible in real time,” said Siemering, who works with Arriaga. “What we found was reassuring, on the whole, but also suggests that better system management could improve how the water is treated and further reduce the possibility of nitrogen entering groundwater.”
The $255,000 project was funded by the Midwest Food Processors Association, Wisconsin Cheese Makers Association, and the state DNR.
When nitrate is added to the soil, it can be taken up by plants, held temporarily in the soil, drained to groundwater or released to the atmosphere. Because nitrogen infiltration into groundwater from such large sites can be difficult to measure, measuring releases to the atmosphere should improve calculations about nitrogen’s fate.
“Wisconsin (Administrative) Code is written really well from a scientific point of view,” says Siemering. “It says you can apply as much nitrogen as is taken up by the cover crop plus how much is denitrified in the soil, but there was no way to quantify the denitrification. That’s what we have tried to do: to give a number and say this is how much we think is being released to the atmosphere as nitrogen gas.”
The study made repeated measurements of nitrogen release at disposal systems used by three cheesemakers and three vegetable processors in Wisconsin. Data were gathered from probes buried in the soil. Gas was collected from the soil surface during several one-week periods at different times of the year.
The heart of the system was a series of automated sampling chambers connected to a photoacoustic analyzer. The analyzer, based on an 1880s invention by Alexander Graham Bell, identifies elements by exposing samples to specific wavelengths of light, and then measuring the sound waves that are generated. This system measured nitrogen gas exiting the soil every few minutes.
Wastewater disposal is a daily need at Del Monte’s canning factory in Cambria, says facility manager Al Bodden. The cannery processes green beans, peas and sweet corn for about five months every year, employing about 260 people. Del Monte has similar needs at its operations at Plover, Wisconsin, and Mendota, Illinois.
Each day, the Cambria plant pumps about 300,000 gallons of wastewater, mainly from washing, blanching and cleaning, to a nearby hayfield, where a center-pivot irrigator quietly drips it onto the soil.
The stakes in the study are high, as vegetable and cheese production are significant industries in Wisconsin, with thousands of jobs in growing and processing. According to the UW–Madison researchers, “In 2017, the Wisconsin vegetable processing industry ranked second nationally, behind only California, in total production.” In 2017, Wisconsin ranked first in snap beans production and third in sweet corn and green peas. These crops resulted in between 2.4 and 5.5 billion gallons of wastewater.
Producing 3.3 billion pounds of cheese in America’s Dairyland creates about 5.6 billion gallons of an effluent that carries a higher concentration of nitrogen than cannery wastewater, and is typically disposed of in furrows. Although some large cheese facilities use in-plant wastewater treatment systems, that solution is exorbitantly expensive for vegetable processors who operate seasonally and for small and mid-size cheese plants.
In both industries, the study results could affect the cost of disposal, by raising or lowering the need for land and equipment.
The new results should help the DNR refine disposal permits so vegetable processors and cheesemakers can maximize the amount of wastewater disposal while still protecting the environment, says Siemering.
The study results also provide evidence-based suggestions for maximizing nitrogen removal:
- Better fertilization and care for cover crops at disposal sites, to retain more nitrogen in crops that can be harvested and used
- Optimizing cheesemaker systems
- Raising the level of organic carbon in the soil to increase the microbial activity that underlies denitrification